Filters Close slideover Filters Collection Other Specialties Toppings Celebration Bars Special Considerations Gluten Friendly Dairy Friendly Vegan Friendly Sort By Recommended Most Recent Least Expensive Most Expensive Filter Milk & Dark Caramel Pecan Patties - 2 Box Set $48.00 Milk Chocolate Caramel Pecan Patties - Box of 6 $24.00 Dark Chocolate Caramel Pecan Patties - Box of 6 $24.00 Toffee & Almonds $14.75 Peanut Butter Cups $12.75 Caramel Pretzels $12.75 Milk Chocolate Butter Cookies $17.00 Indiana Popcorn Tasting Bar $8.50 Mint Cookie Crunch Tasting Bar $8.50 Sea Salt Splash Tasting Bar $8.50 Hazelnut Sea Salt Crisp Tasting Bar $8.50 Tart Red Raspberry Tasting Bar $8.50 Milk Chocolate Tasting Bar $8.50 74% Dark Chocolate Tasting Bar $8.50 White Chocolate Tasting Bar $8.50 Raspberry Cream - Box of 5 $10.75 Rose Carmella - Box of 5 $10.75 Dark Chocolate Sea Salt Caramels - Box of 5 $10.75 Milk Chocolate Sea Salt Caramels - Box of 5 $10.75 Chocolate Race Car $5.75 Pennies From Heaven $5.75 Caramel Pecan Patty Individual - Milk $4.00 Caramel Pecan Patty Individual - Dark $4.00 Box of Chocolate Discs $18.75 Load More